Closing the Gender Pay Gap: Action and Accountability in Today's Hospitality Industry
Setting the Pace for Fairness on the Frontline
have spent most of my career in hotels where shift patterns, seasonality and customer promises make fairness both complicated and essential. When a guest asks for excellence, the way we pay people helps to decide whether our teams can deliver it. This edition combines the legal core of gender pay gap reporting with a wider push for transparent, fair pay that includes ethnicity and disability. The law sets a minimum standard. Culture sets the pace.
Why This Matters Now
In the UK, equal pay for equal work is a legal duty under the Equality Act 2010. Beyond equal pay, larger employers must publish gender pay gap figures each year and keep them online for three years. The current reporting threshold remains 250 employees. Hospitality leaders also need to watch the roadmap under the Employment Rights Bill, which introduces voluntary action plans from April 2026 and mandatory action plans for larger employers in 2027. The government has also signalled a separate Equality Bill that would extend pay gap reporting to ethnicity and disability for employers with more than 250 staff, with consultation already concluded. These changes move the focus from transparency alone to transparency plus action.
In hotels and restaurants, this is not theory. Our sector has casual workers, zero-hours and variable-hours workers, agency staff, and outsourced teams. All of these shape the dataset that underpins published figures and the narratives that follow. If we want credibility with our people and the public, we need to be precise, transparent, and practical.
What the Law Requires in Plain English
Here is the core, simplified for busy operators:
Who must report: Private, public, and voluntary organisations with 250 or more employees on the annual snapshot date must calculate and publish gender pay gap data. The term "employee" is extended to include employees, workers, apprentices, some self-employed who personally perform work, and agency staff counted by the agency. Casual and zero-hour workers are in scope for headcount and often for calculations.
When to measure and publish: The Private and voluntary sector snapshot date is 5 April each year, with a publication deadline of 4 April the following year. The public sector snapshot date is 31 March, with a 30 March deadline.
What to calculate: Mean and median hourly pay gaps. Mean and median bonus gaps. Proportions of men and women who received a bonus. Proportions by pay quartile bands. Figures should be rounded to one decimal point and accompanied by a signed accuracy statement from a senior leader.
What to include: Ordinary pay includes basic pay, holiday pay, shift premiums, piece rates, and common allowances such as on-call, car, or location. Over time, redundancy, pay in lieu of leave, salary sacrifice deductions and benefits in kind are excluded. Working hours exclude overtime. Variable hours require a clear averaging method over the defined period.
What happens if you ignore it: The Equality and Human Rights Commission can enforce compliance and investigate breaches. Public naming is real, reputational risk is real and persistent non-compliance can escalate to court orders and fines.
That is the baseline. Compliance is not the finish line.
Action Planning That Actually Reduces Gaps
Many employers publish the numbers and a short note. High-performing employers publish the numbers, name the causes, and run a plan as seriously as a brand standard. In hospitality, the barriers are usually a mix of structural and cultural. Here is the approach I have used and recommend.
1) Diagnose with discipline
Build a clean dataset and validate contract types, salary sacrifice, allowances and variable hours calculations. Segment by function and location. Kitchen, front office, housekeeping, spa, reservations, sales, revenue and support teams rarely share the same profile. Look at representation by pay quartile and feeder roles into leadership. A gap is often a pipeline problem rather than a single pay decision. Test bonus design. Discretionary bonus plans can produce uneven outcomes even when base pay looks fair. Examine return-to-work journeys after parental leave and the availability of flexible patterns in roles that set the pace and culture.
2) Interventions that move the numbers
Transparent ranges should be included in every job advert and every internal move. State the range and the factors that determine positioning. Use structured selection with the same questions, scoring rubrics and job-related work samples. Replace unstructured chats with observable skills and evidence. Ensure shortlists include multiple women for every promotion round and senior hire, balanced across shifts and sites, so the process is not a paper exercise. Set fixed rules for starting pay and pay progression that reduce manager discretion without removing recognition for impact, and publish these rules internally.
Design flexibility into rota creation, split leadership patterns and job shares in key leadership roles. When senior people model it, the culture follows. Parental leave confidence can be built through simple guidance, proactive outreach before return dates, and visible stories from senior leaders who have taken leave. Targeted development is required for feeder roles where the pipeline thins, for example, senior sous chefs into head chef roles, head housekeepers into operations leadership and assistant revenue managers into revenue heads.
3) A narrative that earns trust
A narrative is voluntary but essential. It should do three jobs: explain the figures in context, set clear actions and milestones, and show progress, not slogans. In hospitality, tell the story property by property and function by function. Share the wins and the misses. Your people can tell the difference between marketing and honest leadership.
The Outsourced and Casual Reality
Many hospitality businesses rely on outsourced housekeeping, security, engineering or kitchen brigades at peak times. The direction of travel is towards fuller inclusion of outsourced workers in reporting and narrative. Even where the legal duty sits elsewhere, reputational accountability sits with the brand on the door. At a minimum, could you include outsourced teams in your internal analysis and action plans? If your guest experience depends on a team, your fairness story should include that team.
Casual and variable-hour workers are part of our model. Get the working hours calculations right. Where information cannot be reasonably obtained for individuals who personally provide services, record the limitation and explain it in your narrative. Be consistent, and avoid convenient gaps. Credibility beats convenience.
Beyond Gender to Fair Pay and Transparency
The coming Equality Bill would extend pay gap reporting to ethnicity and disability for larger employers. Now is the time to prepare your data foundations. Record ethnicity and disability with care, communicate purpose and privacy, and begin internal analysis even before it becomes mandatory. When the public reporting arrives, you will already be working your plan rather than scrambling for a narrative.
Hospitality specifics I have learned the hard way:
Service charge and bonuses: Where service charge or TRONC sits outside basic pay, audit gender patterns in roles that attract large shares. Transparency and clear rules help to avoid hidden disparities.
Rota fairness: Prime shifts and high tipping windows can distort take-home outcomes. Share premium windows fairly and rotate access to development opportunities that lead to promotion.
Returners and midlife talent: Women returning from career breaks often have deep service instincts and systems fluency. Build returner pathways with buddying, confidence-building, and accelerated refreshers.
Hotels within a group: Publish group-wide numbers, then manage by property. The real conversations happen with the teams who recognise themselves in the data.
Quick Answers to Common Questions
Can casual workers bring an equal pay claim? Yes. Equal pay protections apply to employees, workers, agency staff, apprentices and some self-employed who personally perform the work. Success depends on showing like work, equivalent work or work of equal value compared with a valid comparator of the opposite sex and that there is no material factor defence.
Do furloughed employees count? Counting rules and calculation rules differ. For headcount, they are usually counted. For hourly pay calculations, only full-pay relevant employees are included for that snapshot, while bonus calculations include relevant employees even if not on full pay at the snapshot.
Should we write a narrative? Yes. It is voluntary but smart. Explain drivers, set actions, give timelines and report progress each year.
In a Nutshell
What has changed: Pay gap reporting is moving from passive transparency to mandatory action plans, with potential expansions covering ethnicity and disability.
Why it matters: In hospitality, complex workforce structures, including casual and outsourced staff, make fairness highly visible and essential for trust.
What happens if leaders ignore it: Persistent non-compliance brings reputational damage, legal enforcement, and a loss of credibility with frontline teams.
What improves when they act early: Clear narratives and disciplined action plans build trust, narrow the gap, retain top talent, and ultimately elevate the guest experience.
Key Takeaways for Hospitality HR Leaders
Compliance is not the finish line: Use data to diagnose pipeline problems and structural barriers rather than just ticking a reporting box.
Intervene with structure: Implement transparent pay ranges, structured interviews, and fixed rules for starting pay to remove biased discretion.
Control the narrative: Write a voluntary narrative that explains the context of your data, sets clear milestones, and shares both wins and misses honestly.
Prepare for the future now: Begin establishing data foundations for ethnicity and disability reporting before legislation makes it mandatory.
Stay Ahead in Hospitality HR
HR Horizons delivers weekly, practical insights for leaders in hotels, restaurants, and hospitality groups.
If you want stronger teams and more resilient workplaces, subscribe and join a growing community shaping the future of hospitality.
